Crane Research Forum recap: What we can learn from afterschool programs about literature, ELA instruction, and relationships

September 2020
written by Janelle Williamson

Crane’s first-ever virtual research forum hosted Dr. Dorian Harrison, assistant professor in teaching and learning at The Ohio State University, Newark Campus who shared her work on literacy instruction in after-school programs.

Some 10.2 million children in the U.S. are enrolled in after-school programs, with African American and Latinx children twice as likely as their white peers to be enrolled in after-school programs. Low-income areas often experience a lack of available programs, with long waitlists of children who need after-school services. In Ohio, for every child in an after-school program, there are three children on the waitlist. Dr. Harrison’s research on literacy in after-school programs is based on qualitative methods; in this presentation she shared findings on a well-loved after-school program in a predominately black neighborhood. Using the art of storytelling, Dr. Harrison painted a picture of the literacy practices used by a tutor with 2nd grader “Sam,” a reluctant reader, who is self-described as “silly, fast, and strong-willed.”

View or download the slides here.

Key Highlights:

  • Relationship building and playtime are important in literacy activities. For example, instead of reading side-by-side as prescribed, “Sam” and his tutor read in a fort they built together.
  • Being competent in a child’s culture plays a role in effective literacy instruction.
  • Student choice in shared book reading is important. For example, instead of reading the assigned shared-book reading for the day, “Sam” desperately wanted to read Captain Underpants. Did the assigned curriculum get completed that day? No. Did engaging literacy instruction occur? Yes.

Action Steps:

Literacy programs (after-school and other) should prioritize relationships and instruction. Practitioners should welcome a child’s home literacy practices (i.e., reading in a fort), while being aware that their instruction approaches are biased to our own experiences. Practitioners should use a curriculum as a guide, but seek to understand and incorporate a child’s literacy wants and needs.

Crane Center Research Forums are held monthly throughout the university-calendar year, and feature researchers from across the university and Ohio who share their research and its impact on children and families.

See our upcoming offerings here.